Proposed Medicare Advantage Changes Cannot Accurately Be Called 'Cuts,' Experts Say

“It’s President Biden who is proposing to cut Medicare Advantage.”

Sen. Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) in a tweet on February 6, 2023

More than 60 million people rely on Medicare for health coverage, and raising the alarm about potential cuts to the program is a perennial talking point among both Republicans and Democrats.

On Feb. 6, Sen. Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) took a swing at President Joe Biden on Twitter after Biden tweeted that House Republicans were threatening to cut Social Security and Medicare.

“It’s President Biden who is proposing to cut Medicare Advantage, a program used by almost 4 in 10 Arkansas seniors,” Cotton wrote.

It wasn’t clear from Cotton’s tweet which Biden proposal he was referring to, and his office did not respond to requests for comment.

��policies, administered through Medicare-approved private insurance companies, bundle the traditional Medicare program’s separate hospital, medical, and prescription drug coverage into one plan.

The plans are optional and can��while offering other benefits, including vision and dental services, that are not included in the original Medicare program.��

About 28 million people, or nearly half of those eligible for Medicare, were enrolled in Medicare Advantage plans in 2022, .

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services recently announced two proposed changes that could affect Medicare Advantage insurers:��

One is a��, set to take effect April 3, that’s intended to increase the government’s ability to audit Medicare Advantage plans and recover past overpayments.��
The other is an��that would modify Medicare Advantage’s risk adjustment model, which determines how much the government pays insurers for beneficiaries’��reported health conditions.��

Health care policy experts said it is most likely that Cotton’s tweet was referring to the��intended to increase the government’s ability to recover overpayments.

The rule change would return billions of dollars to the federal government and is likely to reduce private insurers’��profits, though experts say the reductions would be minimal compared with overall spending.��

Those companies might, in turn, increase enrollees’��out-of-pocket costs or reduce benefits, experts said. But it is unclear if that will happen.��

Meanwhile, the second change — an annual update to the rates paid to Medicare Advantage insurers — will reduce payments to Medicare Advantage insurers. But the reductions will be offset by other program modifications that are projected to yield a 1% increase in Medicare Advantage spending per person in 2024.

A group that lobbies for Medicare Advantage plans sent a��that said proposed changes would affect 30 million beneficiaries, .

What Is the Proposed Rule Change to Medicare Advantage?

The federal government pays private insurance companies for Medicare Advantage per patient, making adjustments to the amounts based on the health of a beneficiary.

The sicker a Medicare Advantage patient is, the more money a private insurer will receive from the federal government to cover the cost of care. Experts said there’s been a longtime concern that Medicare Advantage insurers have a financial incentive to identify preexisting conditions among enrollees.

Auditors from the federal government review medical files to confirm whether patients have the diseases that their private insurers listed, KHN has reported. These audits showed that private insurers had ��for patients that could not be verified, resulting in millions of dollars of overpayments to .

When overpayments are identified, private insurers��the difference to the federal government.

The administrative��that would allow the government to recoup overpayments is a new version of a rule , under the Trump administration. The final rule comes after the government ��how to identify and recover overpayments, experts said.

“The essence of this rule is to set up procedures whereby the Medicare program can recoup the overcharge,” said Joseph Antos, a health policy expert at the American Enterprise Institute, a conservative-leaning think tank.

From 2023 through 2032, , the federal government will recover $4.7 billion in overpayments from major insurance companies including Humana, UnitedHealthcare, and Aetna. That money represents about one-fifth of 1% of federal payments to Medicare Advantage plans during that period,��, director of Medicare’s Center for Program Integrity.

Though the rule change is expected to reduce private health insurance companies’��revenues from Medicare Advantage plans, the Department of Health and Human Services doesn’t consider that to be a “cut.”��

“Auditing plans and recouping funds puts money back in the Medicare trust funds when big insurance companies get caught taking advantage of the Medicare program,” Kamara Jones, a spokesperson for the department, told PolitiFact. This is about “holding our seniors’ health care to the standard they deserve.”

CMS is also required��to ensure accurate payments and prevent fraud, waste, and abuse.��

Experts said they would not characterize the rule change as a “cut.”��

The federal government is attempting to avoid paying more than it should, said Paul Ginsburg, a senior fellow at the University of Southern California Schaeffer Center for Health Policy and Economics. “To me, that is simply running the program better and more efficiently to protect the integrity of the federal funds being used for it.”

How Will Enrollees Be Affected?

It’s difficult to determine whether Medicare Advantage enrollees will feel the rule changes.��

“My read of the evidence is that reductions in payments to Medicare Advantage plans are largely borne by the plans themselves, either through lower profits or cost reductions,” said Matthew Fiedler, a senior fellow with the University of Southern California-Brookings Schaeffer Initiative for Health Policy.

A ��from Avalere, a health care consulting company, found that the rule change could result in beneficiaries facing higher costs or fewer plan options or benefits.

Because private insurers’��profits will be reduced, companies could pass along those costs to enrollees in small ways, including slight increases in insurance premiums or out-of-pocket costs and, in some cases, fewer benefits, the American Enterprise Institute’s Antos said.

Antos said he did not expect drastic cost increases or benefit reductions that would encourage enrollees to turn to non-Medicare Advantage plans.

��that the other proposed 2024 updates to the way Medicare Advantage insurers will be paid will result in about a 3% reduction in payments to Medicare Advantage insurers in 2024. But the agency said that other modifications to the Medicare Advantage program would offset that reduction and yield a 1% increase in spending per person in 2024.

An insurers’��lobbying group said��CMS did not provide adequate information about how it arrived at the 1% figure. “Consequently, there is no way to validate the accuracy” of that estimate, a spokesperson said.

The proposed 2024 adjustments are not a cut, but are part of “the routine annual process of implementing the law as far as how Medicare Advantage plans are paid,” USC’s��Ginsburg said.��

Our Ruling

Cotton said, “It’s President Biden who is proposing to cut Medicare Advantage.”

Experts said Cotton likely was referring to a recent rule change that allows the government to recover overpayments to insurers and is expected to reduce insurers’��profits. Those companies might, in turn, raise enrollees’��out-of-pocket costs or reduce benefits. It is unclear whether that will happen.��

Another proposed change, an annual update to the rates paid to Medicare Advantage insurers, will reduce payments to insurers. But reductions will be offset by other changes that are expected to yield a 1% increase in payments to insurers per person in 2024.��

Experts say it’s inaccurate to characterize the changes as a “cut” to Medicare Advantage. We rate it False.

PolitiFact researcher Caryn Baird contributed to this report.

Sources

��by Sen. Tom Cotton, Feb. 6, 2023

Federal Register,��“,” Feb. 1, 2023��

The New York Times,��“, Jan. 30, 2023

Avalere,��“,” Aug. 23, 2022

Axios,��“,” Jan. 30, 2023

KHN,��“CMS Signals That Medicare Advantage Payments Will Decline in 2024,” Feb. 2, 2023��

KFF,��“,” Nov. 10, 2022

KFF,��“,” Jan. 19, 2023

Stat,��“,” Feb. 1, 2023

Fierce Healthcare,��“,” Oct. 29, 2018

Centers for Medicare &��Medicaid Services,��“,” accessed Feb. 9, 2023

NPR,��“,” Nov. 21, 2022

KHN,��“Medicare Failed to Recover up to $125 Million in Overpayments, Records Show,” Jan. 6, 2017

Fierce Healthcare,��“,” Jan. 30, 2023

Interview with Joseph Antos, senior fellow and Wilson H. Taylor scholar in health care and retirement policy at the American Enterprise Institute, Feb. 9, 2023

Interview with Matthew Fiedler, senior fellow with the University of Southern California-Brookings Schaeffer Initiative for Health Policy, Feb. 9, 2023

Statement from�� Kamara Jones, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services spokesperson, Feb. 9, 2023

Interview with Jeannie Fuglesten Biniek, associate director of the Program for Medicare policy at KFF, Feb. 9, 2023

Interview with Bowen Garrett, senior fellow in the Health Policy Center at the Urban Institute, Feb. 9, 2023

Interview with Paul Ginsburg, senior fellow at the University of Southern California Schaeffer Center for Health Policy and Economics and a professor of health policy at the University of Southern California Price School of Public Policy, Feb. 9, 2023

Centers for Public Integrity,��“,” Aug. 29, 2016

Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation,��“,” published March 2022��

KFF,��“,” March 23, 2021

Centers for Medicare &��Medicaid Services,��“,” Jan. 30, 2023

Centers for Medicare &��Medicaid Services,��“,” Feb. 1, 2023

Centers for Medicare &��Medicaid Services,��“” published April 2015

Medicare.gov,��“,” accessed Feb. 14, 2023

Social Security Administration, Social Security Act:��, accessed Feb. 14, 2023

Social Security Administration, Social Security Act:��“, accessed Feb. 14, 2023

Social Security Administration,��Social Security Act: “, accessed Feb. 14, 2023

Politico,��“,” Feb. 8, 2023

��ϳԹ�� News is a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about health issues and is one of the core operating programs at KFF—an independent source of health policy research, polling, and journalism. Learn more about .

<h2>Proposed Medicare Advantage Changes Cannot Accurately Be Called ‘Cuts,’ Experts Say</h2>
<div>	Madison Czopek, PolitiFact and Yacob Reyes, PolitiFact
		<time class="posted-on" datetime="2023-02-22T05:00:00-05:00">
			February 22, 2023		</time>
		</div>
“It’s President Biden who is proposing to cut Medicare Advantage.”Sen. Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) in a tweet on February 6, 2023More than 60 million people rely on Medicare for health coverage, and raising the alarm about potential cuts to the program is a perennial talking point among both Republicans and Democrats.	On Feb. 6, Sen. Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) took a swing at President Joe Biden on Twitter after Biden tweeted that House Republicans were threatening to cut Social Security and Medicare.“It’s President Biden who is proposing to cut Medicare Advantage, a program used by almost 4 in 10 Arkansas seniors,” Cotton wrote.It wasn’t clear from Cotton’s tweet which Biden proposal he was referring to, and his office did not respond to requests for comment.��policies, administered through Medicare-approved private insurance companies, bundle the traditional Medicare program’s separate hospital, medical, and prescription drug coverage into one plan.The plans are optional and can����while offering other benefits, including vision and dental services, that are not included in the original Medicare program.��About 28 million people, or nearly half of those eligible for Medicare, were enrolled in Medicare Advantage plans in 2022, .The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services recently announced two proposed changes that could affect Medicare Advantage insurers:��<ul><li>One is a��, set to take effect April 3, that’s intended to increase the government’s ability to audit Medicare Advantage plans and recover past overpayments.��</li><li>The other is an����that would modify Medicare Advantage’s risk adjustment model, which determines how much the government pays insurers for beneficiaries’��reported health conditions.��</li></ul>Health care policy experts said it is most likely that Cotton’s tweet was referring to the����intended to increase the government’s ability to recover overpayments.The rule change would return billions of dollars to the federal government and is likely to reduce private insurers’��profits, though experts say the reductions would be minimal compared with overall spending.��Those companies might, in turn, increase enrollees’��out-of-pocket costs or reduce benefits, experts said. But it is unclear if that will happen.��Meanwhile, the second change — an annual update to the rates paid to Medicare Advantage insurers — will reduce payments to Medicare Advantage insurers. But the reductions will be offset by other program modifications that are projected to yield a 1% increase in Medicare Advantage spending per person in 2024.A group that lobbies for Medicare Advantage plans sent a����that said proposed changes would affect 30 million beneficiaries, .What Is the Proposed Rule Change to Medicare Advantage?The federal government pays private insurance companies for Medicare Advantage per patient, making adjustments to the amounts based on the health of a beneficiary.The sicker a Medicare Advantage patient is, the more money a private insurer will receive from the federal government to cover the cost of care. Experts said there’s been a longtime concern that Medicare Advantage insurers have a financial incentive to identify preexisting conditions among enrollees.Auditors from the federal government review medical files to confirm whether patients have the diseases that their private insurers listed, <a href="/news/article/medicare-advantage-audits-investigation-cms-overpayment-recoup-billions/">KHN has reported</a>. These audits showed that private insurers had ��for patients that could not be verified, resulting in millions of dollars of overpayments to .When overpayments are identified, private insurers����the difference to the federal government.The administrative����that would allow the government to recoup overpayments is a new version of a rule , under the Trump administration. The final rule comes after the government ��how to identify and recover overpayments, experts said.“The essence of this rule is to set up procedures whereby the Medicare program can recoup the overcharge,” said Joseph Antos, a health policy expert at the American Enterprise Institute, a conservative-leaning think tank.From 2023 through 2032, , the federal government will recover $4.7 billion in overpayments from major insurance companies including Humana, UnitedHealthcare, and Aetna. That money represents about one-fifth of 1% of federal payments to Medicare Advantage plans during that period,��, director of Medicare’s Center for Program Integrity.Though the rule change is expected to reduce private health insurance companies’��revenues from Medicare Advantage plans, the Department of Health and Human Services doesn’t consider that to be a “cut.”��“Auditing plans and recouping funds puts money back in the Medicare trust funds when big insurance companies get caught taking advantage of the Medicare program,” Kamara Jones, a spokesperson for the department, told PolitiFact. This is about “holding our seniors’ health care to the standard they deserve.”CMS is also required������to ensure accurate payments and prevent fraud, waste, and abuse.��Experts said they would not characterize the rule change as a “cut.”��The federal government is attempting to avoid paying more than it should, said Paul Ginsburg, a senior fellow at the University of Southern California Schaeffer Center for Health Policy and Economics. “To me, that is simply running the program better and more efficiently to protect the integrity of the federal funds being used for it.”How Will Enrollees Be Affected?It’s difficult to determine whether Medicare Advantage enrollees will feel the rule changes.��“My read of the evidence is that reductions in payments to Medicare Advantage plans are largely borne by the plans themselves, either through lower profits or cost reductions,” said Matthew Fiedler, a senior fellow with the University of Southern California-Brookings Schaeffer Initiative for Health Policy.A ��from Avalere, a health care consulting company, found that the rule change could result in beneficiaries facing higher costs or fewer plan options or benefits.Because private insurers’��profits will be reduced, companies could pass along those costs to enrollees in small ways, including slight increases in insurance premiums or out-of-pocket costs and, in some cases, fewer benefits, the American Enterprise Institute’s Antos said.Antos said he did not expect drastic cost increases or benefit reductions that would encourage enrollees to turn to non-Medicare Advantage plans.��that the other proposed 2024 updates to the way Medicare Advantage insurers will be paid will result in about a 3% reduction in payments to Medicare Advantage insurers in 2024. But the agency said that other modifications to the Medicare Advantage program would offset that reduction and yield a 1% increase in spending per person in 2024.An insurers’��lobbying group said��CMS did not provide adequate information about how it arrived at the 1% figure. “Consequently, there is no way to validate the accuracy” of that estimate, a spokesperson said.The proposed 2024 adjustments are not a cut, but are part of “the routine annual process of implementing the law as far as how Medicare Advantage plans are paid,” USC’s��Ginsburg said.��Our RulingCotton said, “It’s President Biden who is proposing to cut Medicare Advantage.”Experts said Cotton likely was referring to a recent rule change that allows the government to recover overpayments to insurers and is expected to reduce insurers’��profits. Those companies might, in turn, raise enrollees’��out-of-pocket costs or reduce benefits. It is unclear whether that will happen.��Another proposed change, an annual update to the rates paid to Medicare Advantage insurers, will reduce payments to insurers. But reductions will be offset by other changes that are expected to yield a 1% increase in payments to insurers per person in 2024.��Experts say it’s inaccurate to characterize the changes as a “cut” to Medicare Advantage. We rate it False.PolitiFact researcher Caryn Baird contributed to this report.<h4>Sources</h4>��by Sen. Tom Cotton, Feb. 6, 2023Federal Register,��“,” Feb. 1, 2023��The New York Times,��“, Jan. 30, 2023Avalere,��“,” Aug. 23, 2022Axios,��“,” Jan. 30, 2023KHN,��“<a href="/morning-breakout/cms-signals-that-medicare-advantage-payments-will-decline-in-2024/">CMS Signals That Medicare Advantage Payments Will Decline in 2024</a>,” Feb. 2, 2023��KFF,��“,” Nov. 10, 2022KFF,��“,” Jan. 19, 2023Stat,��“,” Feb. 1, 2023Fierce Healthcare,��“,” Oct. 29, 2018Centers for Medicare &��Medicaid Services,��“,” accessed Feb. 9, 2023NPR,��“,” Nov. 21, 2022KHN,��“<a href="/news/medicare-failed-to-recover-up-to-125-million-in-overpayments-records-show/">Medicare Failed to Recover up to $125 Million in Overpayments, Records Show</a>,” Jan. 6, 2017Fierce Healthcare,��“,” Jan. 30, 2023Interview with Joseph Antos, senior fellow and Wilson H. Taylor scholar in health care and retirement policy at the American Enterprise Institute, Feb. 9, 2023Interview with Matthew Fiedler, senior fellow with the University of Southern California-Brookings Schaeffer Initiative for Health Policy, Feb. 9, 2023Statement from�� Kamara Jones, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services spokesperson, Feb. 9, 2023Interview with Jeannie Fuglesten Biniek, associate director of the Program for Medicare policy at KFF, Feb. 9, 2023Interview with Bowen Garrett, senior fellow in the Health Policy Center at the Urban Institute, Feb. 9, 2023Interview with Paul Ginsburg, senior fellow at the University of Southern California Schaeffer Center for Health Policy and Economics and a professor of health policy at the University of Southern California Price School of Public Policy, Feb. 9, 2023Centers for Public Integrity,��“,” Aug. 29, 2016Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation,��“,” published March 2022��KFF,��“,” March 23, 2021Centers for Medicare &��Medicaid Services,��“,” Jan. 30, 2023Centers for Medicare &��Medicaid Services,��“,” Feb. 1, 2023Centers for Medicare &��Medicaid Services,��“” published April 2015Medicare.gov,��“,” accessed Feb. 14, 2023Social Security Administration, Social Security Act:��, accessed Feb. 14, 2023Social Security Administration, Social Security Act:��“, accessed Feb. 14, 2023Social Security Administration,��Social Security Act: “, accessed Feb. 14, 2023Politico,��“,” Feb. 8, 2023<ul><li><a href="/news/article/tom-cotton-medicare-advantage-biden-fact-check/?share=x">				Click to share on X (Opens in new window)				X			</a></li><li><a href="/news/article/tom-cotton-medicare-advantage-biden-fact-check/?share=facebook">				Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)				Facebook			</a></li><li><a href="/news/article/tom-cotton-medicare-advantage-biden-fact-check/?share=linkedin">				Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)				LinkedIn			</a></li><li><a href="mailto:?subject=%5BShared%20Post%5D%20Proposed%20Medicare%20Advantage%20Changes%20Cannot%20Accurately%20Be%20Called%20%27Cuts%2C%27%20Experts%20Say&body=https%3A%2F%2Fkffhealthnews.org%2FMTYyNDc2MA&share=email">				Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)				Email			</a></li><li><a href="/news/article/tom-cotton-medicare-advantage-biden-fact-check/">				Click to print (Opens in new window)				Print			</a></li><li>				<a href="/news/article/tom-cotton-medicare-advantage-biden-fact-check/view/republish/">					Republish This Story				</a>			</li></ul><a href="/about-us">���ϳԹ��� News</a> is a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about health issues and is one of the core operating programs at KFF—an independent source of health policy research, polling, and journalism. Learn more about .<a href="/morning-briefing/">Subscribe</a> to ���ϳԹ��� News' free Morning Briefing.This <a target="_blank" href="/news/article/tom-cotton-medicare-advantage-biden-fact-check/">article</a> first appeared on <a target="_blank" href="">���ϳԹ��� News</a> and is republished here under a <a target="_blank" href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nd/4.0/">Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License</a>.<img src="/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2023/04/kffhealthnews-icon.png?w=150" style="width:1em;height:1em;margin-left:10px;">
<img id="republication-tracker-tool-source" src="/?republication-pixel=true&post=1624760&amp;ga4=G-J74WWTKFM0" style="width:1px;height:1px;">

Some elements may be removed from this article due to republishing restrictions. If you have questions about available photos or other content, please contact NewsWeb@kff.org.

���ϳԹ���

Sources

More From ���ϳԹ��� News

��ϳԹ��

More From ��ϳԹ�� News