The vast majority of older adults receive long-term care at home, not in nursing homes. But few people plan for this expense.
Nor do they see long-term care insurance as a viable option 鈥� because it鈥檚 expensive and is often seen as protection against the cost of nursing home care.
That should change, some experts contend. If the long-term care insurance industry focused more on helping people cover home-based services, they argue, policies would be more affordable, and potentially appealing.
鈥淟ong-term care, for most people, is a home care problem,鈥� said Bill Comfort, who owns , a brokerage based in St. Louis and Durham, N.C.
鈥淚t makes sense to insure people for the likelihood of where care is going to be needed first 鈥� which is at home,鈥� agreed Deb Newman, president of in Richfield, Minn., outside Minneapolis.
Genworth, one of the nation鈥檚 leading long-term care insurers, acknowledged that this position is supported by industry claims data.
鈥淧rimarily, we are seeing people utilizing home care and a smaller and smaller percentage using nursing home care,鈥� said Beth Ludden, Genworth鈥檚 senior vice president for long-term care insurance products.
鈥淧eople think, 鈥榃hile I might start out needing care at home, eventually I鈥檒l need to be in a facility,鈥欌�� Ludden continued. 鈥淏ut that鈥檚 not something we see in our data. For the most part, people are able to stay at home for the whole time.鈥�
Currently, more than 6 million older Americans are thought to have a 鈥渉igh need鈥� for long-term care, according to a . That鈥檚 defined as requiring daily assistance with two activities (eating, bathing, toileting, dressing, continence or transferring from a bed to a chair) that lasts at least 90 days or a need for substantial assistance due to severe cognitive impairment.
About 52 percent of adults reaching age 65 today will need these services 鈥� 26 percent for two years or less; 12 percent for two to four years; and 14 percent for more than five years, the HHS report projected.
Yet fewer than 10 percent of older adults have purchased long-term care insurance, which has declined in popularity as premiums skyrocketed and insurers exited the market over the past decade. Whether the industry can fix its major problem 鈥� affordability 鈥� remains to be seen.
From a consumer鈥檚 perspective, if your goal is covering several years of home-based care, not nursing home care, you can purchase a less expensive policy without all the bells and whistles that drive up costs, Newman suggested.
A 55-year-old couple buying a policy of this kind 鈥� say, $4,000 a month in benefits for each person, for a maxiumum of three years, with a 1 percent compounded annual inflation protection provision 鈥� from Mutual of Omaha would pay $2,380.05 a year in premiums, according to a quote from Minnesota that her firm provided. It鈥檚 common for policyholders to pay premiums for 10 or 20 years before claiming benefits. Terms are similar in many other states.
How much help in the home might this policy provide?
According to , the average annual cost for care provided by a home health aide was $46,332, compared with $82,128 for a semiprivate room in a nursing home. That translates into $3,861 a month, for 44 hours of home care a week 鈥� the equivalent of slightly more than six hours of care, seven days a week.
That might not be enough for seniors with serious, disabling illnesses, but it can provide much-needed relief to unpaid family caregivers who could otherwise be on call nonstop.
What happens if someone ends up needing nursing home care?
You might consider what鈥檚 known as a 鈥渜ualified long-term care partnership policy鈥� 鈥� a plan available in every state except Alaska, Hawaii, Illinois (where a program has been approved but policies aren鈥檛 available yet), Massachusetts, Mississippi, New Mexico, Vermont and Washington, D.C. (The Mutual of Omaha quote above is for a partnership policy.)
These little-known insurance products are designed to help consumers preserve their assets if they become seriously ill, need nursing home care and seek to become eligible for Medicaid, which pays for nearly half of nursing home costs in the U.S.
To qualify for Medicaid, most states require that an individual have no more than $2,000 in assets; couples are allowed to have up to about $120,000, so that a well spouse doesn鈥檛 become impoverished. With a partnership policy, every dollar received in long-term care benefits is exempted from Medicaid鈥檚 asset test and protected from seizure by the state.
In other words, if you get $200,000 in benefits from a partnership policy and your state has an asset limit of $2,000 for Medicaid, you can keep $200,000 in assets plus the $2,000 allowed and still meet your state鈥檚 asset test, said Scott Olson, co-founder of the .com, a brokerage based in Camano Island, Wash.
He noted that partnership policies don鈥檛 guarantee Medicaid eligibility and you鈥檒l still have to meet whatever income standards your state sets for Medicaid. (Many, but not all states, allow people to 鈥渟pend down鈥� to qualify, using their income to pay for institutional care.)
Bill Nickerson, 63, of Las Vegas, one of Olson鈥檚 clients, purchased a partnership policy three years ago because it lets him 鈥渞etain control of my financial assets, even if I have to be cared for.鈥� Another plus: The policy 鈥減ermits me, if I decide to stay home, to take a certain amount聽of the monthly amount and give it to someone who I choose to provide care for me, even if that person is a family member.鈥�
There鈥檚 no reliable national data about how many people with partnership policies end up going on Medicaid to cover nursing home care. Nor is there good data about the number of these policies that have been sold or the benefits paid out to date.
David Guttchen, who directs the , the first such program in the country, is skeptical about policies with benefits that will cover only a portion of expected costs. (Four states, including Connecticut, were the first to launch partnership programs and have special rules.)
鈥淵ou absolutely need to know what the average home care and nursing home costs are for your state, to get a sense of what your exposure might be,鈥� he said. 鈥淚f you don鈥檛 buy meaningful benefits, you鈥檙e wasting your premium.鈥�
If you鈥檝e been able to cover a good amount of home care but your policy won鈥檛 cover nursing home care, you鈥檝e gained some protection, for a while, but you could still pay an enormous amount out-of-pocket going forward, if Medicaid isn鈥檛 an option.
It鈥檚 a gamble because people can鈥檛 be sure what kind of care they鈥檒l need in the future, or for how long, or what the future of Medicaid will look like, said Michael McDonnell, an insurance broker in Petaluma, Calif. Before buying any policy, consult with an elder law attorney or independent financial adviser, he recommended.
We鈥檙e eager to hear from readers about questions you鈥檇 like answered, problems you鈥檝e been having with your care and advice you need in dealing with the health care system. Visit to submit your requests or tips.
KHN鈥檚 coverage of end-of-life and serious illness issues is supported by . Its coverage related to aging & improving care of older adults is supported by and its coverage of aging and long-term care issues is supported by .